Michael Smith

What you trade Rashard Mendenhall, Brandon Marshall, and Michael Crabtree for Kevin Smith and Larry Fitzgerald?

Ok so my RBs are: Chris Johnson, Rashard Mendenhall, Willie Parker, Willis McGahee, and Jamal Lewis

My WRs are: Roddy White, Steve Smith(NYG), Brandon Marshall, Austin Collie, Johnny Knox, and Michael Crabtree

Im being offered Fitz and Smith for those 3

What do u think? Is this a good trade? and if not, What should I counter with to make it fair?

The RBs:
Youre DOWNGRADING by trading off Mendenhall for Smith! Mendy is finally THE MAN in Pittsburgh. Johnson and Mendy are your two STARTERS at the position. McGahee and Lewis are spot starts vs weak Run Defenses at best. Parker of course lost his spot to Mendy, so that speaks for itself.

The WRs:
Larry Fitzgerald for Brandon Marshall and Michael Crabtree? Naw, I wouldnt do that one! Marshall is becoming a top tier reciever, and will surpass Fitz’s end of the year totals in receptions and yards, if not TDs as well. Crabtrees gonna be money, but its gonna take him a bit to get to that level of play, and of course, hes not got the solid QB to get the ball to him consistently, so curb expectations with him for awhile.

If youre really wanting Kevin Smith, offer up Lewis and McGahee for Smith… I think the dude would jump on that one, depending on his other compliments to his RB slots.

Good luck. Hope this helps you make a great decision that brings much success your way.